I tried the nose butter on my boxer and it didn't work, so I tried the paw butter in his nose and it has been 5 days with using it and his nose is almost back to normal. He has been dealing with a crusty nose for 3 years until now. This year it was getting worse. The picture I took of his crust nose was in October 2020. I didn't take a picture before I started using the paw butter last week. I tried the blissful nose butter on his nose first and it didn't work, so that's why I decided to use the paw butter. I will start using the paw butter on his paws starting tomorrow to see if it works on his paws. I love the tube because I don't have to use my fingers.